My husband and I watched Close Encounters of the Third Kind last night—rewatched, technically, but neither of us had seen it in decades, and our memory of it was quite patchy. (Devils Tower in mashed potatoes? And a mothership with lights? And those five notes? And...couldn't remember much else.)
Verdict: We loved it! These many decades later, after countless sci-fi shows and films in which every scientific thing is explained in meticulous jargony detail in a super-tense high-security-briefing scene, and the aliens are almost always apocalyptically menacing, Close Encounters feels like a beautiful, dreamy, eerie art film.
A lot is left only hinted at, even completely unexplained, and actually I loved that. It infuses the film with a sense of wonder, akin to discovering that the fae are real (but still scientifically inexplicable). I also liked that the aliens—along with the government agencies—are essentially nice. No one's out to kill anyone. There's a big cover-up going on, and uncanniness and frustration abound, but nobody is evil.
And damn, I think I miss that in sci-fi, which lately is almost always about how Aliens And/Or The Government Are Trying To Kill You. A premise of which I am tired, apparently.
Thank you for your gentleness and for your willingness to include beauty and wonder in an alien story, Steven Spielberg.
I think it also captures both the optimism and paranoia of the 1970s (or early 80s?). On one hand, you have characters discovering: DON'T BELIEVE THEY GOVERNMENT OR THE MEDIA! LIKE WATERGATE, THERE'S CORRUPTION WE CAN'T SEE! But by the same token, the "conspiracy" is gentle and wonderful -- and you think, "Yeah, well, maybe people *shouldn't* know about this, cuz they'll fuck it up." The government is trusted to do this one thing RIGHT. You can really see the different fault lines colliding. Unfortunately, it feels like the paranoid lunatic and burn-it-down types won out, and this is now the world we live in. Sighhhhh.
I revisited it myself a few years ago and I was surprised how great it was. Of course a fantastic score by John Williams doesn't hurt!
(The only part I thought was odd was how everyone was okay that Richard Dreyfus was leaving his family.)